Yes, since opening the website back in october 2010, you members have posted over 7,000 tops.. We passed the 7,000 mark in June actually!
That's a lot of pages, not all are good I admit it. But still, the traffic is capped at a little over 2,000 unique visitors a day, as can be seen here:
What happened in march when we were at a little over 3,000 unique visitors a day is that I have created a second site, due to adsense acting up and disabling the ads for 2 weeks, remember? http://www.best-reviewers.com is the new site and on that site I moved all salary pages (a little over 600) as well as copying the existing top pages at the time.. So now on this old/original site the traffic is the same as before minus the traffic to the salary pages which are redirected to the new site..
The thing is, the new site, despite being new, gets about the same amount of traffic as the old one, a little over 2,000 unique visitors per day.. It seems it is capped at about the same figure..
This is the tracker for the new site: http://extremetracking.com/open;unique?login=dam010
Anyway, the point is that we get relatively small traffic for the content we have and it seems it is capped by Google at a certain amount daily, it's always the same figure despite more and more content being added everyday..
So hopefully Google will soon realize that we are good people who deserve at least 20,000 unique visitors a day..
Just to compare, the french version of best reviewer has about half the number of tops and its traffic is capped at 10,000 unique visitors a day!!! It has been like that for the last 3 months.. And even before that it was over 5,000 a day.. Have a look: http://extremetracking.com/open;unique?login=dam001
I know that on french web it is easier to rank high because the competition between webmasters is lower, but there are also way less people surfing on the french web than on the english web! That would make sense to receive at least the same amount on Best Reviewer, wouldn't it? Mind you it is not about quality here, because the tops are of various level of quality on the french site as well as on the english site.
What can I do in order to try to increase that traffic from Google, say double or triple it? Do you have any tips or similar experience that you can share? What have you done that resulted in significant increase of traffic from Google? That would be nice to know, honestly!
And by the way if you know someone at Google, like if you're related to Matt Cutts, please tell him to increase the capping on Best Reviewer, thank you in advance! :-)